I build OKRs Tool, and I tested Profit.co hands-on in a real account — same objective, Key Results, owners and check-in setup — then scored both on one rubric: what makes goals get hit. Here's where each one wins.
Founder, OKRs Tool · tested every OKR platform in a real account since 2017
Requires a named owner and a score on every Key Result, runs check-ins on its own, and gets a team live in an afternoon at one flat, public price — no configuration project required.
The most feature-complete mid-market platform — OKRs, KPIs, reviews, 1:1s and compensation in one AI-powered system. It takes 4–6 weeks to configure, and pricing is quote-only.
Profit.co is the most complete system on my list — and the slowest to start. It connects OKRs to every layer of performance, now wrapped in AI, but takes weeks to configure. OKRs Tool strips to the habits that get goals hit and is live in an afternoon. The choice is depth and governance versus speed and enforced discipline.
OKRs Tool is my own product, so I know it from the inside; Profit.co I set up in a real account — the same objective, two Key Results, owners and check-in flow. I scored both on the same rubric, built on platform data across 3,527 organizations that shows which habits move the odds of hitting a goal. I publish where OKRs Tool falls short, lower down.
Pick Profit.co if you need OKRs connected to every layer of performance — KPIs, reviews, 1:1s and compensation — in one governance-heavy system, and you have the weeks of configuration its depth demands. Pick OKRs Tool if you want a named owner and a score required on every Key Result, a transparent flat price, and a team live this afternoon rather than next quarter.
The most complete suite on the list. Also the slowest to start.
Profit.co covers more ground than any other mid-market platform, now AI-powered with Athena agents. But implementation runs 4–6 weeks before the first cycle, and it has removed its public tiers, so there's no price without a sales call. OKRs Tool enforces ownership and is live in an afternoon at a flat, published rate.
Everything below I checked in a live account, not from a pricing page.
| Capability | OKRs Tool | Profit.co |
|---|---|---|
| Named owner required on every Key Result | Required | Optional |
| Score required on every Key Result | Enforced | Optional (weighted scoring) |
| Automatic check-in reminders | Yes | Yes |
| Time to first cycle | Live in an afternoon | 4–6 weeks of config |
| Performance suite (reviews, 1:1s, comp) | 360 reviews | Full suite |
| AI features | AI KR analysis | Athena AI agents |
| Pricing transparency | Flat, public | Quote-only |
| Cost | From $129/mo, flat | ~$10k–$17k/yr (reported) |
| EU data residency | Yes (Ireland) | US-based |
| Free trial | 14 days, no card | 30 days, no card |
Checked in a live account. Feature availability and pricing shift — confirm current terms with each vendor before you buy.
Profit.co covers more ground than any other mid-market platform. OKRs, KPIs, task management, performance reviews, 1:1s and compensation planning all live in one system, now branded an AI-powered strategy execution platform with a suite of Athena AI agents and usage-based credits. The weighted scoring is a genuine strength, rewarding nuanced goal design, and for a governance-heavy organization that needs OKRs connected to every layer of performance and operational reporting, nothing else on the list is this complete. If depth is what you're buying and you have the time to configure it, Profit.co gives you the most.
OKRs Tool requires the two habits my data shows matter most — a named owner and a score on every Key Result — rather than leaving them optional. A team goes from signup to a live cycle in about an afternoon, not weeks of configuration, check-ins fire automatically in Slack, Teams and email, and the price is flat and published, from $129 a month for the whole organisation. Data stays in the EU by default. It's the stronger pick when you want the habits enforced and value getting live fast over a configurable governance stack.
We need reviews, comp and KPIs alongside OKRs — doesn't Profit.co win?
On breadth, yes. Profit.co's performance suite — 360 reviews, 1:1s, compensation planning, operational KPIs — goes well beyond OKRs Tool, which is OKR-focused with 360 reviews. If you need the full governance stack in one system, Profit.co is the more complete option. If OKR execution is the priority and you want to be live fast, OKRs Tool fits better.
What does Profit.co cost?
There's no public price anymore. Profit.co removed its published tiers and free plan, so pricing is quote-only; third-party buyers report roughly $10k–$17k a year depending on scope. OKRs Tool is flat and published, from $129 a month for the whole organisation, with no sales call to see a number.
How long until we're running a cycle?
On Profit.co, plan for 4–6 weeks of configuration before the first cycle — that depth is the point, but it's real setup time. On OKRs Tool, a team goes from signup to a live cycle in about an afternoon, with ownership enforced from the start.
Did you test both hands-on or read the feature pages?
I build OKRs Tool, so I know it from the inside, and I set up the same OKR in Profit.co in a real account — signup, an objective, two Key Results, owners and the check-in flow. The table reflects what each live product does, not what a pricing page claims.
Open a free trial, create an objective, and watch the check-ins run themselves.
Benchmark figures from The OKR Benchmark Report. Feature scoring from a live account test of both tools.